Celebrity Idol?

Would you want to watch a "Celebrity Idol" TV show in which Simon, Randy, and Paula have well-known and popular celebs perform on live television? I would!

-Who would make your top ten--or, if you can't think of that many people--your top five?

Celebrity Idol?headache

Some of the singers today are so awful they would never cut it on AI. And they are out there selling records and selling out concerts. Go figure...

Celebrity Idol?paramount theater opera theater

Since it's a hypothetical thing, do they all still have to be alive, or of the American Idol age range (I can't think of many who are)? If not, the singers I think would make the best contestants (by vocals only) for Idol are...

GIRLS

1.Christina Aguilera

2. Amy Lee (Evanescence)

3. Dolores O'Riordan (The Cranberries)

4. Sinead O'Connor

5. Celine Dion

6. Whitney Houston

7. Aretha Franklin

8. Karen Carpenter

9. Bette Midler

10. Annie Lennox

11. Sarah McLachlan

GUYS

1.Freddie Mercury

2.Roy Orbison

3.Sebastian Bach ( Skid Row)

4.Chester Bennington (Linkin Park)

5.Layne Staley (Alice in Chains)

6.Josh Groban

7.Barry Mannilow

8.Serj Tankian (System Of A Down)

9. Chad Gray (Mudvayne)

10. Eric Burdon (The Animals)

11. John Lennon

12. Elton John

Wouldn't that make an interesting show??? :p